root labs rdist

September 7, 2012

Toggl time-tracking service failures

Filed under: Security — Nate Lawson @ 10:33 am

A while ago, we investigated using various time-tracking services. Making this quick and easy for employees is helpful in a consulting company. Our experience with one service should serve as a cautionary note for web 2.0 companies that want to sell to businesses.

Time tracking is a service that seems both boring and easy to implement but is quite critical to most companies. Everyone from freelance writers to international manufacturers needs some system, ranging from paper and spreadsheets to sophisticated ERP systems. For a consulting company, lost time entries means lost money.

As we added employees last year, we began evaluating various web-based time tracking services in comparison to our home-grown system (flat text files).

We considered using Toggl, but our experiences with it started ok but got worse as they grew. We found that some test entries would disappear occasionally. The desktop widget was really an HTML app wrapped in a full browser (they started with Qt and moved to Chrome).

Then one day, we found that their servers had screwed up access control and everyone was being logged into a single account. You can see the messages in the attached screenshots. This was at once hilarious and horrifying, and we terminated our account immediately. No customer or sensitive data was lost, but there was no way we were ever going to use this service. There were various complaints about all this on the Toggl forums, but those posts were deleted when they updated their support website.

Dealing with distributed systems and the CAP theorem is particularly hard. Startups ignore this at your own (or your customers’) peril. Time tracking seems simple enough, but you can never lose data. For customers that don’t use code names for clients/projects, a data compromise could be devastating.

I debated whether to write this post since I don’t have a grudge against Toggl. However, I am hoping our experience will be informative as to what can happen when you outsource ownership of data that is directly tied to your revenue.

The Rubric Theme. Blog at WordPress.com.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 89 other followers